E.H. Barnum could fit lots of information in his ads for the combs manufactured at his Plattsburgh factory in early 1834. He boasted the best prices and the best assortment of superior quality combs made by experienced workmen – and, as we will see, workwomen.
Comb factories had been flourishing in the colonies since before the American Revolution. Combs were a basic commodity needed to remove lice, oil and other types of dirt from the human head which did not get washed as we do today. They were also used extensively in the grooming of horses.
At first, making combs was very manual but in 1799 Phineas Pratt patented a machine run by “foot, wind or water” that would reduce the time it took to cut and polish a comb. We can speculate a machine of this type was used at the Plattsburgh Comb Factory as Barnum used the term “manufacture” consistently.
Amazing too was the assortment of combs available from the Plattsburgh Comb Factory – genuine tortoise shell (sea turtle), Ivory, Brazilian shell, imitation Brazilian shell, horn and hoof. Sources for the latter two were local and the Barnum ads reminded farmers he would pay cash and good prices for horns and hoofs (only those which had not been boiled). Sources for the first three mentioned are today on the endangered species list.
We think of shells and horns as hard but with heat applied they become pliable so they can be flattened, made into decorative and functional combs and then rehardened. Broken combs could be repaired by reheating so that was a service also offered by the Plattsburgh Comb Factory. Like early starch factories, comb factories did seem to have an unusual number of fires.
Barnum also advertised for employees. His ad called for “smart active” boys between the ages of 14 and 16 to learn the trade. Girls too, with recommendations, could apply and were promised good wages paid in cash. A couple of years after his ad for apprentices appeared, he advertised that he had “highly experienced” staff.
Barnum advertised his combs and comb repair services in Burlington, Plattsburgh and St. Lawrence County. Initially orders were to be sent to local business man Douglass Fouquet. Fouquet was involved in a diverse line of businesses with his name associated with woolens, cabinets, dry goods, and his hotel, the Fouquet House.
Later ads directed merchants and peddlers to the comb factory itself on east Bridge Street with the promise of prompt service and quality product.
The comb factory added a positive dimension to the Plattsburgh area. In a June 1836 article promoting the “flourishing village” of Plattsburgh to investors, a comb factory was one of the industries listed.
We do not have any information on exactly how the factory operated but we can assume it was similar to the factories in Northborough, Massachusetts, which boasted six comb factories in 1850 with machines run by water power operated by men who cut the combs from the sheets of shell, horn and hoof and women who shaped, polished and packaged the finished comb.
Barnum didn’t own his facility, but leased it for $145 a year and by 1845 there was no further mention of the factory or of E.H. Barnum. He was never noted in the 1840 area census.
Ancestry.com does identify an E.H. Barnum living in Amsterdam, New York in 1850 whose occupation is machinist and later in Broadalbin, New York in 1855 as an “insurance agent” with two children, Elizabeth and Frank, born in Clinton County but that is as close as we could get to this early Plattsburgh entrepreneur.
The Clinton County Historical Association has 18 combs in its collection matching the descriptions found in Barnum’s ads but none can be directly connected to those his business provided locals for over 10 years.
One dates to about 1790 and was a comb worn by Mary Hay Elmore, daughter of one of the first couples to marry in what is now Peru, New York. Her grandfather was William Hay, an early settler of Peru Landing.
Another comb in the CCHA collection with age is made of ivory and designed to remove lice from a child’s head.
Photos, from above, from the Clinton County Historical Association: A comb owned by Mary Hay Elmore ca. 1790; and an ivory comb for a child.
This essay was first published in the Plattsburgh Press Republican.

Leave a Reply