Octagon houses date back to ancient Greece, where they were symbols of rebirth and renewal. In the United States they were mostly built during the 1850s and 1860s, many of them in New York State.
Most were inspired by Orson Squire Fowler’s book The Octagon House: A Home for All, published in 1848. Born in Cohocton, Steuben County, NY in 1809, Fowler became a phrenologist, a racist pseudoscience aimed at determining character and intelligence from the size and shape of a person’s cranium. It was a forerunner of the more modern eugenics movement.
He also analyzed the shape of houses, believing the sphere to be more beautiful than the angular. He was from a devout family and at first studied for the ministry in Amherst, Massachusetts. There he befriended Henry Ward Beecher and together they attended lectures on phrenology.
After graduating from Amherst in 1834 he opened a phrenology practice in the city of New York with his brother Lorenzo. He also lectured, and published several books and journals, including The Phrenological Journal, the antisemitic Hereditary Descent, Physiology, Mental and Animal (which proposed a vegetarian diet) and Self- Culture and Perfection of Character.
Somewhat paradoxically Fowler also championed the causes of abolition and women’s suffrage, but also children’s rights when child labor was widely practiced.
When he turned his attention to octagon houses, he determined that they let in more light and were easier to heat and cool.
In 1849 he began to build his own octagon house in Fishkill, Dutchess County, New York, completed in 1853. It was four stories high, had 100 rooms, and was decried as “Fowler’s Folly.” Octagon houses declined after the Civil War, though a few continued to be built into the 1890’s.
Fowler relocated his office to Massachusetts in 1863, where the 1880 census listed him as a phrenological professor, in Manchester.
Despite Orson Fowler’s influence on octagonal architecture and the many houses which still stand today, he died in August 1887 at his home in Sharon Station, Connecticut in relative obscurity, apparently the result of his 1870 sex manual, Sexual Science, Including Manhood, Womanhood, and Their Mutual Interrelations, which damaged his reputation.
Orson Fowler is buried in an unmarked grave in Woodlawn Cemetery in The Bronx.
The following is a list of some octagon houses located in upstate New York.
- Younglove House, Urbana near Hammondsport, Steuben Co., 1859, built by surveyor and wine maker Timothy M. Younglove. It is now the Blacksheep Inn, on the National Register. Younglove family diaries, including Timothy’s are online here.
- Rich-Twinn House, Akron, Erie Co., 1849, built by Charles B. Rich, later bought by lawyer Clark Twinn in 1940, then by Newstead Historical Society in 1981. It is listed on the National Register. A September 1956 Democrat and Chronicle article mentioned that Charles B. Rich was an Indian agent and grain buyer. His May 1870 obituary in the Buffalo Courier News stated that a large number of Indians respectfully paid tribute to “one whom in life they had learned to esteem and love as a friend and benefactor.” Clark Twinn was a lawyer who lost his eyesight but continued to practice law with the help of a young partner.
- Hyde House, Mumford, Monroe Co., about 1870, built for physician and spiritualist Dr. Erastus C. Hyde after the Civil War. It was originally in Friendship, Allegany Co., NY and later moved to Genesee Country Village & Museum in Mumford.
- Barneveld – Trenton, Oneida Co., 1852, built by carriage maker Jacob Wicks.
- Wilcox House, Camillus, Onondaga Co., 1856, home of Isaiah Wilcox who had a large sheep and cattle farm. Isaiah was an abolitionist, and the house is rumored to have been on the Under Ground Railroad.
- Armour-Stiner House, Irvington, Westchester Co., 1860’s, built by NYC financier Paul J. Armour. It was purchased in 1872 by Joseph Stiner, a tea merchant. Today, there are tales of ghosts at this National Historic Landmark.
- Lily Vale, Unadilla, Otsego Co., 1855, built by tanner & shoemaker Selek Fancher.
- Estabrook House, Hoosick Falls, Rensselaer Co., 1853, built by Ezra Robinson Estabrook.
- Fowler’s Folly, Fishkill, Dutchess Co., (now the town of Wappinger), built during 1848-1853. The home of Orson Fowler for a short time, it had 4 stories and 100 rooms. It was later rented, then demolished in 1897. There is an article and Illustration of Fowler’s Folly in the Poughkeepsie Journal, Oct 1, 2014.
- David Van Gelder House – Springside, Catskill, Greene Co., 1860, built by David Van Gelder, farmer and builder known for covered bridges. There is an interesting 2022 article in Chronogram about the house and its current owner, artist and spiritualist Jesse Bransford. The article mentions that “much of Fowler’s thinking was borne out of the spiritualist movement, and their beliefs state that octagonal structures encourage the visitations of spirit.” It is on the National Register of Historic Places.
- Jenkins House, Duanesburgh, Schenectady Co., 1855, built by master carpenter Alexander Delos “Boss” Jones. He also built the Shute House in Duanesburgh, 1855. The house is on the State Historic Register.
- Pratt-Buckingham House, Fredonia, Chautauqua Co., 1865, built by journalist Levi Louis Pratt, editor of a Fredonia newspaper. His father was an architect.
- Coolidge House, Madison, Madison Co., 1850, cobblestone exterior.
- Dubois-Sarles House, Marlboro, Ulster Co., 1850.
- Mattice House, Fultonham, Schoharie Co., 1853. It was built by brothers John Calvin Mattice and Henry Mattice. The Schoharie Co. Historical Review published an article about the house in 1983.
- Denton House, Geneva, Ontario Co., 1853, built for agriculturist Nehemiah Denton and wife. Their properties were later used for New York’s Agricultural Experiment Station at Geneva.
Additionally, the New York Heritage digital collections website contains photos and descriptions of octagon houses and barns throughout upstate here. New York here.
Wikipedia has created a list of some 68 still-standing octagon houses throughout the country, listed by date they were built.
Illustrations, from above: David Van Gelder Octagon House in Catskill, NY (photographed in 2008 by wikimedia user ); Fowler’s plan for an octagonal house from The Octagon House: A Home for All, 1848; and a lithograph of the Orson Squire Fowler Octagonal Mansion in Fishkill.

Not exactly off-topic. Thinking out loud here. Half an Octagon House. There is a late 20th century SQUARE house in the Village of Rouses Point, Clinton County NY. When I first saw it, my reaction was: Oh! What a great way to maximize daylight and VIEWS. Two of the four equilateral faces are directed eastward toward Lake Champlain.
BTW, Woodlawn Cemetery in The Bronck’s NY is located just East of I-87, as it enters NYCity from Yonkers. Many more characters of interest to visit are buried there in ‘marked’ graves. Just sayin …
“The Octagon House: A Home For All.” He believed octagonal homes offered superior ventilation, more usable space, and a more aesthetically pleasing appearance compared to traditional rectangular structures.
Topsider Homes in Clemmons, NC has been building octagon homes for years now. Me and my wife are planning to build one around Boone mountain area once we find some property. https://www.topsiderhomes.com