• Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

New York Almanack

History, Natural History & the Arts

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Adirondacks & NNY
  • Capital-Saratoga
  • Mohawk Valley
  • Hudson Valley & Catskills
  • NYC & Long Island
  • Western NY
  • History
  • Nature & Environment
  • Arts & Culture
  • Outdoor Recreation
  • Food & Farms
  • Subscribe
  • Support
  • Submit
  • About
  • New Books
  • Events
  • Podcasts

Rough And Tumble: A Short History of Eye Gouging

September 7, 2022 by John Warren 2 Comments

Retired NYPD officer Thomas Webster, dubbed the 'eye gouger,' attacks a DC police officer in a still from January 6th videoLast week Thomas Webster, a 20-year veteran of the NYPD, was sentenced to the stiffest sentence so far – 10 years – for his actions while attacking the U.S. Capitol on January 6th in an effort to keep Donald Trump in power. In the effort to identify the insurrectionists, Webster was given the name “eye-gouger” for his attempt to gouge the eyes of a Washington D.C. police officer.

It’s a long American tradition. Eye gouging, not insurrection.

“There are a great many different modes of fighting,” one Lansingburgh, NY writer observed in 1870. “We have in Pugilism the rough-and-tumble, the gouging, the fair and square stand-up-to-the-scratch-and-take it fight, and other kinds too numerous to mention.” Although less frequent in the northern states, and after the Civil War, American history is full of gouging.

Historian Elliott Gorn has studied early rough-and-tumble fights and their attendant eye gouging, biting and maiming. He centers the practice in the southern states, noting that in the 1740s it was common enough that the North Carolina colonial assembly made it a felony “to cut out the Tongue or pull out the eyes of the King’s Liege People.”

Virginia followed suit in 1752, noting that “many mischievous and ill disposed persons have of late, in a malicious and barbarous manner, maimed, wounded, and defaced, many of his majesty’s subjects, then very specifically makes it a felony to put out an eye, slit the nose, bite or cut off a nose, or lip.”

Later, in 1772, Virginia revised its statute to make it clear that “gouging, plucking, or putting out an eye, biting or kicking or stomping upon” a peaceable citizen was a crime.  Gorn notes that 1780s South Carolina “made premeditated mayhem a capital offense, defining the crime as severing another’s bodily parts.”

“The best gougers, of course, were adept at other fighting skills,” Gorn wrote in his 1985 essay for The American Historical Review, “Gouge and Bite, Pull Hair and Scratch’: The Social Significance of Fighting in the Southern Backcountry.”

The hands of celebrated gougers from drawings reproduced in Richard M Dorson's Davy Crockett - American Comic Legend (1939)“Some allegedly filed their teeth to bite off an enemy’s appendages more efficiently. Still, liberating an eyeball quickly became a fighter’s surest route to victory and his most prestigious accomplishment. To this end, celebrated heroes fired their fingernails hard, honed them sharp, and oiled them slick.”

Gorn notes the practice of gouging was attested to from Louisiana to Ohio, where it was outlawed in 1821. Edward Allen Talbot, who wrote a narrative of his travels, Five years’ residence in the Canadas: including a tour through part of the United States of America, in the year 1823, said the practice was also widespread there:

“The principal object of the combatants appears to be the calculation of eclipses; or, in other words, their whole aim is bent on tearing out each other’s eyes, in doing which they make the fore finger of the right hand fast in their antagonist’s hair, and with the thumb, —as they term it,— gouge out the day-lights. If they fail in this attempt, they depend entirely on their teeth for conquest; and a fraction of the nose, half an ear, or a piece of a lip, is generally the trophy of the victor.”

“To such an extent is this method of boxing carried in the Southern States of America,” Talbot wrote, “that when the people of New England or those of Canada observe a man who has only one eye, and the place where the other is not, they commonly say that he has received a Virginian brand.”

“I kept my thumb in his eye, and was just going to give it a twist and bring the peeper out, like taking a gooseberry in a spoon,” Davy Crockett once said about one of the rough-and-tumble fights he engaged in.

The practice was however, undoubtedly far less common in the northern more urbanized areas, although there are examples from New York history.  The boxer Howell Gardner, known by his cognomen “Horrible” (the brother of Orville “Awful” Gardner, both friends and training partners of prize-fighter John Morrissey), once said “in sheer brutality, a prize fight isn’t half as desperate and bad as a street or barroom fight, where there is biting and kicking and gouging out eyes and all that.”

A street fight illustrated in The Crockett Almanac (Nashville, 1840)In 1848, the Poughkeepsie Journal reported that Charles Smith was found guilty “of gouging out the eye of another man with whom he was fighting.” He was sentenced to 21 years in state prison. “The laws of this State in reference to maiming are very severe, and we think very justly so,” the paper opined. “It is one of the most heinous crimes of which man can be guilty.”

In 1859, Billy Mulligan and Pat Matthews engaged in an impromptu rough and tumble fight at Platt’s Saloon in the city of New York.  They gouged and Mulligan’s nose was bitten off, marking him for life as a “rough.”

In 1867, Harry Nolan and Bill Colton fought for nearly forty minutes on the Palisades. Nolan bit off one of Colton’s ears and a thumb. Colton took a chunk out of Nolan’s cheek.

Gorn describes much of the motivations for eye-gouging and maiming during rough and tumble fights, and it’s a complicated milieu of factors, among them:

“Violence and poverty were part of daily existence, so endurance, even callousness, became functional values. Loyal to their localities, their occupations, and each other, men… craved one another’s recognition but rejected genteel, pious, or bourgeois values, awarding esteem on the basis of their own traditional standards.”

Much of that quote rings familiar today in light of the actions of the NYPD’s Thomas Webster.

Illustrations, from above: Retired NYPD officer Thomas Webster, dubbed the ‘eye gouger,’ attacks a DC police officer in a still from January 6th video; The hands of “celebrated gouger” from drawings reproduced in Richard M. Dorson’s Davy Crockett: American Comic Legend (1939); and a street fight illustrated in The Crockett Almanac (Nashville, 1840).

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: Capital-Saratoga, History, New York City Tagged With: boxing, Crime and Justice, Cultural History, Lansingburgh, Medical History, New York City, Poughkeepsie, Social History, Vice, Virginia

About John Warren

John Warren is founder and editor of the New York Almanack. He's been a media professional for more than 35 years with a focus on history, journalism and documentary production. He has a master's degree in Public History and is on the staff of the New York State Writers Institute, a center for literary arts based at the University at Albany. John lives in the Adirondack Park. His weekly Adirondack Outdoors Conditions Report airs across Northern New York on the North Country Public Radio network.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Bob Meyer says

    September 7, 2022 at 9:01 PM

    Damn John… this makes me twinge in places best left untold. 🤣🥴.

    Reply
  2. Richard Daly says

    September 8, 2022 at 7:47 AM

    John: Shame on Tom. So, this is NOT the guy who wrote the American-English dictionary. Phew! Does it make your article SFW, fam-friendly, or … Inquirin minds wanna know. PS: Because of YOU, I am smarter. 😉

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Help Finish Our 2022 Fundraising

Subscribe to New York Almanack

Subscribe! Follow the New York Almanack each day via E-mail, RSS, Twitter or Facebook updates.

Recent Comments

  • Ralph on Skiing Comes to the Sullivan County Catskills
  • Bernard McCann on Old Fort Niagara During the Civil War
  • Ellen Brown on The Adirondack Park Agency At 50: State Leaders Are Missing The Point
  • Edythe Ann Quinn on Black History Historiographic Genealogies: Sources & Resources
  • Your New Neighbor on Saratoga Corruption & The Destruction of Cale Mitchell
  • Joyce Kelly- Feeley on Troy Orphan Asylum: Vanderheyden’s Legacy Exhibit Opening
  • Adrienne Saint-Pierre on Hibernation: How It Works
  • GARY SCHOEN on Moose Are Back in New York State: A Population Update
  • Deb Heller on Catskills Resort History: The Beginning of the End
  • John Warren on Civil War in the Mohawk Valley: The Battle of Oriskany

Recent New York Books

The Great New York Fire of 1776
The Sugar Act and the American Revolution
battle of harlem hights
Ladies Day at the Capitol
voices of wayne county
CNY Snowstorm book front cover
The Struggles of Boston's Black Workers in the Civil War Era
Expanded Second Edition of Echoes in These Mountains
historic kingston book

Secondary Sidebar

preservation league
Protect the Adirondacks Hiking Guide