• Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

New York Almanack

History, Natural History & the Arts

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Adirondacks & NNY
  • Capital-Saratoga
  • Mohawk Valley
  • Hudson Valley & Catskills
  • NYC & Long Island
  • Western NY
  • History
  • Nature & Environment
  • Arts & Culture
  • Outdoor Recreation
  • Food & Farms
  • Subscribe
  • Support
  • Submit
  • About
  • New Books
  • Events
  • Podcasts

A Rochester Worker’s Cottage Has Lessons For Today

March 17, 2019 by Linda Day 10 Comments

Worker Cottage PlanI grew up in an immigrant neighborhood close to downtown Rochester, New York in the 1950s. People displaced during the Second World War, along with migrants from the American South and Puerto Rico, were the newest arrivals to my part of the city (settled by Europeans in the last decades of the 19th century).

The housing stock was old. Our house was built in 1895 by a German immigrant laborer from a pattern book plan, many of which were available in German language editions. It was a classic one and half story, front gable, wood frame worker’s cottage. It provided inexpensive housing for the rapidly expanding workforce needed for mid to late 19th-century industrial cities. When I grew up, my single-parent mom’s assembly line job at Bausch and Lomb Optical Company allowed her to be a homeowner and to support her mother and three children.

As 19th-century cities grew to accommodate industry and its workers, affordable housing was a major concern of social reformers. Rochesterian Katherine Bement Davis proposed building the Workingman’s Model home at the 1893 Columbian World Exposition in Chicago to show that a worker could afford an adequate home. Fair organizers thought building a model home was impractical, so the New York State contributors (led by Davis) enlisted Frederick B. Pratt, son of Pratt Institute’s founder, to support the work of Pratt faculty and students in creating plans and working drawings. Pratt agreed because it furthered his goal of providing comfortable housing for the poor of New York City. The result, shown below, was a two-story frame cottage of 1,120 square feet, 20 feet wide by 28 feet deep, that would fit on the 25-foot-wide lot common in American cities.

Workingmans Model Home 1893Our raised basement house at 19 Loomis Street was on a similar sized lot, sited so that one side yard was wide enough for the coal delivery van to position its chute at the cellar window above the coal bin. Except for two bedrooms, one in the front gable and the other in a side dormer, the second story was an unfinished attic with exposed rafters. In the view of us kids, an appealing thing about the attic was that you had to go through the single bathroom to get to its stairs. This led to much hilarity, especially when my older brother, Dickie, found an army surplus gas mask and stored it on the stair landing for the use of passers-thorough when someone was on the toilet.

The bathroom was evidence of the economy of construction and materials that guided the design. As in the Davis plan, there was no sink in the bathroom, just a toilet and a tub positioned against an interior wall, the other side of which held the kitchen sink. This arrangement spared having to run water pipes any further than necessary. Her cottage included a bathroom with just a tub and toilet positioned on opposite sides of the same wall as the kitchen sink to reduce plumbing costs.

Our home heating and hot water systems, although state-of-the-art in 1895, matched the uncomplicated plumbing. The dirt floor cellar had a concrete pad for a coal-burning gravity hot air furnace and a gas-fired water boiler. Furnaces transport heat by natural convection (warm heated air rising) through ducts from the basement to vents in the rooms above. The two attic bedrooms shared ducts with bedrooms on the first floor. Dickie, who had the front attic bedroom, rattled chains over his heat register hoping to scare his younger sister and brother into thinking that there were skeletons of ghosts rattling in the attic. We did not fall for it.

Gottlieb Minkau Though simple and absent of mechanical parts that could go awry, the furnace was labor intensive; it was mostly the labor of Dickie. Starting a coal fire was difficult; having it go out was a household calamity. Once started, the fire had to be continuously tended: stoked in the morning, banked in the evening, ashes removed and sifted for chunks of unburned coal that could be rescued and added to the coal bin. Our house was icy cold on winter mornings.

A tank heater next to the furnace was the source of hot water for Friday night baths. Our mother heated hot water for washing us and the dishes in a teakettle on the gas stove. When we needed a larger quantity of hot water, she slid open the door to the hot water tank in the cellar, turned on the gas, and lit it with a match. Because the heated water would flow by convection up to the top of the tank, drawing in cold water from the bottom, hot water would accumulate in the tank from the top down. Feeling the tank with a hand told when there was enough hot water for a bath. There was no automatic shut off; once the tank was full of hot water, the gas had to be shut off; left on, we were told that the tank would explode. When we were old enough to want more frequent evening baths to be presentable to boy and girlfriends, our mother was unhappy about having to stay up until we had filled the tub. She dared not go to sleep and trust us to remember to turn off the water heater This was not a carefree house to live in; the alternative was visible from our front porch.

Hanover HousesHanover Houses, seven-story multi-unit buildings completed in 1952, were a half mile south. This new housing, the result of the urban renewal undertaken by the city in the 1950s had updated systems, but far less private space. The trade-off was owning a detached home with a big backyard and separate bedrooms for each of us three kids and renting a more compact, warmer home, with an automatic hot water heater and a sink in the bathroom as well as in the kitchen. Our mother said that even though we were within the income eligibility limits, she did not want to live there. In choosing a home that she could own over a new rental apartment, she compromised comfort for the sake of pride of ownership and more private space.

Unlike the more modern urban renewal housing, there were no smoke detectors in our house and access to the attic bedrooms was by narrow, twisty stairs. We had to be ever vigilant about turning off the gas water heater after the tank was full. Coal was cheap enough to make heating an uninsulated house with leaky single pane windows possible, but it was labor intensive.

Despite its shortcomings, it was a great house for kids. In addition to the amusement of the single bathroom being a thoroughfare, we loved the twisty attic stairs and the attic with unfinished portions providing play space with a big corner by a window that I claimed for a play house, with knee walls forming tunnels to crawl into.

Planners for workforce housing today need to consider space and privacy needs. Detached dwellings may not be possible given budget constraints, but the worker’s cottages of yesteryear have lessons for those creating affordable housing today.

Images, from above: Worker’s Cottage Plan, courtesy Lyman Bridges Building Materials & Ready-Made Houses, 1870, reprinted in Bigott; Workingman’s Model Home by Katharine Bement Davis, 1893 Columbian World Exposition, courtesy Report of the Board of Governors, Archives; Gottlieb Minkau, the original owner and builder of our house, in the backyard, courtesy Mary Ellen Lill Campbell, Mr. Minkau’s great-grand-niece; and Hanover Houses, courtesy “Race and Place in the Flower City: A Case Study of Perpetual Marginalization through Urban Planning” by Brennon Thompson.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: History, Western NY Tagged With: Economic Development, Housing, Lake Ontario, Monroe County, Rochester

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Daphne says

    March 18, 2019 at 2:52 PM

    What a fascinating article. I had never heard about the practical difficulties of heating a house and heating water in those older houses — and the fact that people were still dealing with such outdated technology in the 1950s!

    The willingness of architects and builders to build affordable housing for workers in those eras (late nineteenth century until the 1960s probably) is in stark contrast to buildings being put up today, which maximize profit for builders and developers and leave the workers (even construction workers) out in the cold. Lots to learn from here…

    Reply
    • Linda L Day says

      March 19, 2019 at 5:37 PM

      Thank you for your comment. I agree that past times were more supportive of the need for housing that working people can afford. The worker’s cottage was an early urban house type that was modest, but habitable. The bungalow came later and was followed by the Cape Cods — sometimes called “cracker boxes” — of the Levittown era. The basic ranch with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a two car garage was the early suburban affordable house type. Today, developers say that they cannot make affordable housing “pencil out” because of high land costs and upgraded housing codes and other regulatory requirements.

      Reply
  2. James McDonald says

    March 29, 2019 at 3:48 PM

    Interesting article about post-World War Two housing in a moderately sized metropolitan area. It reminded me of growing up in the 10th ward in Rochester, NY and dealing with a gravity fed coal furnace and having to worry about using too much hot water for baths. We also had an attic with passageways that led to other places in the attic. Before that, we had lived in the Lyell Avenue projects which were small attached apartments for returning World War Two veterans. The article also reminded me about how much local history there is in seemingly commonplace things. We are often so much more focused on the big historical events. I liked the idea of the pattern houses and Pratt’s insistence to build comfortable dwellings for factory workers. Thanks to the author for sharing her unique perspectives on housing issues in the post-World War Two era.

    Reply
  3. Linda L Day says

    March 29, 2019 at 7:59 PM

    Thank you for your interesting response. I, too, remember the Lyall Avenue housing. I really liked the bare frame interiors. The walls were open, with just two-by-fours separating the spaces.

    I appreciate the upgraded safety and the energy efficiency improvements of housing built today, but I wonder if some of the funkiness of earlier homes could be retained.

    Here is a recent effort to inspire the building of worker’s cottages.

    “Survival of the starter home: Could a design contest help replenish Chicago’s affordable housing stock?”
    By Lauren Styx

    https://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/disruptive-design-bungalow-starter-home/Content?oid=69144651&utm_campaign=citylab-daily-newsletter&utm_medium=email&silverid=%25%25RECIPIENT_ID%25%25&utm_source=newsletter

    Reply
  4. Mary Stafford says

    March 31, 2019 at 6:15 PM

    I grew up in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Same generation 1950’s in a late 19th century neighborhood, lovely. Learned so much about dealing with everyday life challenges during my years in this wonderful house.
    Linda thank you very much, lot’s of architectural and city planning history from mid American urban experience.
    Mary Stafford
    San Francisco

    Reply
    • Linda L Day says

      April 3, 2019 at 8:33 PM

      I love old houses. However, not being a native Californian, I am fearful of earthquakes. I chose a newly constructed building for the one bedroom apartment that I can afford living here. I do enjoy it being toasty warm and having one and half lavish bathrooms. California.

      Reply
  5. Amy K Elliott says

    April 2, 2019 at 10:59 AM

    Linda,
    great article. Your house reminds me of the rental duplex my family had in Indianapolis in the mid 50’s. Dad would have to load the coal into the furnace several times a day to ensure the house stayed warm. This is crucially important in cold climates where people and water pipes can freeze if the fires aren’t tended. I also appreciated hearing the child’s view of the lack of amenities – such as no sink in the bath, bath being a passageway, and needing to turn of water heater gas. Those inconveniences are minor compared to the fun of nooks and crannies and your own yard to play in in a friendly neighborhood. I note is was diverse as well!

    Amy Elliott
    Charlotte, NC

    Reply
    • Linda L Day says

      April 3, 2019 at 8:37 PM

      Duplexes were prevalent in the old city neighborhood that I described. This is a great house type. They should be built today. It would help more people to be able to afford homeownership. They are a great way of allowing extended families to live close together without living together. Having grandma and grandpa downstairs is a boon to a young family. Owner occupied buildings with rental units are often well maintained because there is someone there who has an investment in the building’s future.

      Reply
  6. Andrea Calfee says

    April 3, 2019 at 9:43 AM

    I enjoyed the article and read it aloud to my local historical society (Rutherford County, TN) at our annual “Show & Tell” banquet. It was greatly appreciated. When our kids were young in the late 70s, we lived in a good-sized, brick Colonial house in Cleveland Heights OH, built c. 1920. The coal chute with access on the driveway had been covered over but the “room” for it was still evident. The old replacement gas furnace was a huge thing. We replaced it with a new unit, more efficient and smaller. However, we soon realized (December) that the large, high-ceilinged kitchen was actually heated by the warmth created by the old furnace in the basement below and that the new one just didn’t do the job. The kitchen sink’s pipes were on the outside wall and had frozen on Christmas morning!

    Reply
  7. Linda L Day says

    April 3, 2019 at 8:28 PM

    Dear Andrea,
    Thank you for your interesting reply. I lived most of my adult life in cold places. My best frozen pipes story is my bungalow in St. Paul, Minnesota with a kitchen that had been added on over an unheated crawl space. A small window between the cellar (home heated by a big furnace such as you describe) had to be left open to heat the crawl space. My department chair was helping rinse dishes after a dinner party and did not notice the flood under his feet as he stood by the sink. Someone had allowed the little window between the crawl space and cellar to snap closed. The kitchen sink pipes were frozen. I had to go under there with my hair dryer to thaw them while my dinner guests amused themselves.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Support Our 2022 Fundraising

Subscribe to New York Almanack

Subscribe! Follow the New York Almanack each day via E-mail, RSS, Twitter or Facebook updates.

Recent Comments

  • Edythe Ann Quinn on Slug Slime: A Secret Weapon
  • Stefani on Jet Ski Invasion of NY Harbor Rounds Manhattan’s Tip
  • Debby Starck on Coyotes: Decoding Their Yips, Barks, and Howls
  • Sean on A Brief History of the Mohawk River
  • Helise Flickstein on Susan B. Anthony Childhood Home Historic Marker Dedication
  • Art and Fashion Teachers Opportunity: Quilts, Textiles, & Fiber Exhibitions Looking For Entries DEADLINE August 14, 2022 – Keeper of Knowledge on Quilts, Textiles, & Fiber Exhibitions Looking For Entries
  • Margaret on Catskills Resort History: The Beginning of the End
  • Kathleen Hulser on Georgia O’Keefe At Wiawaka On Lake George
  • Alison, descendent of Thurlow Weed on Albany’s Thurlow Weed: Seward, Lincoln’s Election, & The Civil War Years
  • Jimmy Wallach on Catskills Resort History: The Beginning of the End

Recent New York Books

off the northway
Horse Racing the Chicago Way
The Women's House of Detention
Long Island’s Gold Coast Warriors and the First World War
Public Faces Secret Lives by Wendy Rouse
adirondack cabin
Spaces of Enslavement and Resistance in Dutch New York
ilion cover
Spare Parts

Secondary Sidebar

preservation league
Protect the Adirondacks Hiking Guide