• Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar

New York Almanack

History, Natural History & the Arts

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Adirondacks & NNY
  • Capital-Saratoga
  • Mohawk Valley
  • Hudson Valley & Catskills
  • NYC & Long Island
  • Western NY
  • History
  • Nature & Environment
  • Arts & Culture
  • Outdoor Recreation
  • Food & Farms
  • Subscribe
  • Support
  • Submit
  • About
  • New Books
  • Events
  • Podcasts

Photo Research and Editing: The John Brown Photos

December 24, 2012 by Chris Pryslopski 1 Comment

It was long past the eleventh hour of my publication timetable and I still needed to get one last image to illustrate the article “‘No Mortal Eye Can Penetrate’: Louis Ransom’s Commemoration of John Brown” which would be appearing in our Autumn issue. I turned to the Library of Congress’s website, found and saved the file along with the metadata in order to be able to cite it correctly, and sent the last of the material to our designer.

Six short weeks later, the Autumn 2012 issue of The Hudson River Valley Review was out to great acclaim, and just a few even shorter days after that I received my first correction. It was about that image, and it was from Jean Libby, who had been cited in the article as the curator and author of the John Brown Photo Chronology. It was clear that I had gotten something wrong.

The good news, it was perfectly legal to use the image and I had cited it correctly. The bad news, it was not really the image that I had thought it was. The image that I intended to use was the portrait of John Brown by Martin M. Lawrence. The article includes a story about author Warren Broderick’s research and discovery of a previously unknown original of this print in the collection of the Herkimer County Historical Society.

Unfortunately for me, the image which he had was not adequate for publication. However his article also revealed that the Library of Congress had another copy of this same rare print in their collection, so that is where I went to find my file. It turns out that what I found was a photo of the original print that had been created by J. W. Black in 1859, by which time both John Brown and Martin Lawrence were deceased. This should have made it clear that I had the wrong image, but Lawrence’s name was listed in the “related names” field and it matched the image that I had been sent. And I had run out of time to research it further, so in it went.

As you can see, the images are virtually the same, though the Black reproduction is more tightly framed, and lacks the pasted autograph, “Your friend John Brown” on the mount. I had in essence accomplished my purpose, to illustrate the article. However, as Ms. Libby quite kindly and patiently pointed out in her letter, my substitution of the more common, derivative image was misleading not to mention inaccurate. It was equally troubling to know that the correct image had been available as well, and it was only by chance, and in haste, that I had made my error. So, you ask, what’s my point?

I guess it is to remind us all that history is fickle; it is easy to err by stopping just one question too soon. It is also to thank historians, especially Ms. Libby, for not being fickle as they share what they have learned…and to share what I found to be an interesting bit of historic whodunnit, and how, with you.  

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: History Tagged With: Chris Pryslopski, Herkimer County Historical Society, Hudson River Valley Review, John Brown, Library of Congress, Photography, Publishing, Recent Publications

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Albert Kaplan says

    April 7, 2014 at 2:09 PM

    Sir:

    Please see the John Brown page of my webite. I would be pleased to hear from you.

    A. Kaplan

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Help Finish Our 2022 Fundraising

Subscribe to New York Almanack

Subscribe! Follow the New York Almanack each day via E-mail, RSS, Twitter or Facebook updates.

Recent Comments

  • Edythe Ann Quinn on Black History Historiographic Genealogies: Sources & Resources
  • Your New Neighbor on Saratoga Corruption & The Destruction of Cale Mitchell
  • Joyce Kelly- Feeley on Troy Orphan Asylum: Vanderheyden’s Legacy Exhibit Opening
  • Adrienne Saint-Pierre on Hibernation: How It Works
  • GARY SCHOEN on Moose Are Back in New York State: A Population Update
  • Deb Heller on Catskills Resort History: The Beginning of the End
  • John Warren on Civil War in the Mohawk Valley: The Battle of Oriskany
  • Richard Daly on Poetry: Mention It, Don’t Insist
  • Norma Coney on Civil War in the Mohawk Valley: The Battle of Oriskany
  • David Forest on Knapp’s Folly: Sullivan County’s Columbia Hotel

Recent New York Books

The Great New York Fire of 1776
The Sugar Act and the American Revolution
battle of harlem hights
Ladies Day at the Capitol
voices of wayne county
CNY Snowstorm book front cover
The Struggles of Boston's Black Workers in the Civil War Era
Expanded Second Edition of Echoes in These Mountains
historic kingston book

Secondary Sidebar

preservation league
Protect the Adirondacks Hiking Guide